Patent Affairs AgencyTrademark and Copyright AgencyLegal AdviceLegal Affairs AgencyCorporate Legal Adviserlegal Aid
In today's highly competitive e-commerce environment, the uniqueness of product design and robust intellectual property (IP) protection have become crucial guarantees for successful business operations. However, IP disputes often bring market obstacles and operational crises. We recently assisted a client in successfully responding to a design patent infringement complaint, swiftly restoring the client's product sales on an e-commerce platform and demonstrating our professional expertise in the field of IP protection.
Case Background:
The client is a company selling lighting products on an e-commerce platform. Its best-selling ceiling lamp product was removed from the platform due to alleged infringement of a competitor's design patent. This complaint severely disrupted the client's normal business operations, leading to a sharp decline in sales and damaging its market reputation. Facing this emergency, the client entrusted us to represent them in the appeal to protect their legitimate rights and interests and restore normal product sales as soon as possible.
Complainant's Subject Patent |
Client's Sold Product |
Case Analysis:
1. Comparison Analysis of the Subject Patent and the Product
Upon receiving the complaint, we immediately conducted a detailed comparison between the client's product and the complainant's subject patent. The complainant's patent involves a design for a "ceiling lamp shade (pebble)," whereas the client's product adopts a shape with three oval-like cross-sections, presenting a completely different overall design style. By comparing the front view, perspective view, top view, and other views, we demonstrated that the client's product has significant differences in shape, structure, and style compared to the subject patent, and therefore does not fall within its scope of patent protection.
2. Prior Design Search and Analysis
During further analysis, we also discovered that the complainant's subject patent was highly similar to a prior design. Through patent searches, we located a design patent filed earlier than the complainant's application and proved that the two are substantially identical in their main design elements. This discovery became the key basis for our petition to invalidate the complainant's patent.
3. Citation of Prior Art
In addition to the prior design comparison, we also collected the client's sales records on the e-commerce platform, discovering that the product or similar products had been widely sold on the market prior to the filing date of the subject patent. We submitted this evidence to the platform to prove that the complainant's subject patent has no significant differences compared to the prior art, thereby further demonstrating the invalidity of the complainant's patent.
Successful Appeal:
We submitted a comprehensive appeal statement to the e-commerce platform on behalf of the client, presenting three main arguments:
1. There are significant differences between the client's product and the subject patent; the overall visual effects are completely different, and therefore, there is no infringement.
2. The subject patent is substantially identical to a prior design, does not comply with the provisions of the Patent Law, and is therefore invalid.
3. The client's product was publicly sold long ago and belongs to the prior art; the subject patent has no significant differences compared to the prior art.
With our professional analysis and sufficient evidentiary support, the e-commerce platform ultimately adopted our appeal arguments, rejected the competitor's complaint, and restored the client's product sales listing.
Summary:
This classic case demonstrates our agency's profound professional capability in handling IP disputes. Through meticulous product comparison, comprehensive patent searches, and the reasonable application of prior art, we successfully helped the client resolve the infringement complaint and restore normal operations on the e-commerce platform. This not only won back market share for the client but also protected its brand reputation.
Our patent agency always places the client's interests at the core. Through professional and rigorous work methods, we help enterprises maintain an invincible position in the complex intellectual property environment.
Patent And Pct Layout And Agency
Intellectual Property Finance and Policy Consultin

Rooms 1304 & 1401, Block B, Building 1, Xingzhan Plaza, No. 446 South Ring Road, Shatou Community, Shajing Subdistrict, Bao'an District, Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, China
ip@lssws.net
0086 13434512348
0086 13434512348

Follow Us
Copyright © 2026 All Rights Reserved. Law firm service website All rights reserved